Pollard's URC Final display — five carries, 10 passes, three missed tackles, three turnovers, and four goal-kicking misses in the semifinal — has drawn sharp criticism, but Erasmus isn't buying the panic. Speaking after the Barbarians rout, he pushed back on the idea of judging players by franchise form, arguing that team environment, game plan fit, and weekly dynamics make club performances an unreliable yardstick. His core defence is simple: Pollard has never let the Boks down when it matters. Erasmus pointed to their working relationship since 2018 and Pollard's role in both World Cup victories as reasons to trust the process over a rough fortnight. Pollard himself has acknowledged the fan frustration, framing it as passion rather than noise. The piece lays out the statistical case against Pollard while stress-testing whether Erasmus's loyalty is justified pragmatism or selective blindness — worth reading if you're weighing how this selection debate plays out ahead of the Rugby Championship.