Hanyani Shimange is confident the Springboks would win a rematch against France, but stops short of pinning the defeat entirely on referee Andrea Piardi — even while arguing Piardi wasn't equipped to handle the pressure of the Stade de France. Shimmy's core critique is that Piardi felt the crowd, retreated from the physical contest at scrum time and set-piece, and didn't get adequate support from his officiating team on the tackle and offside calls that defined the game. The parallel with the All Blacks test is pointed: the Boks kept going to the scrum in search of a penalty reward, but refs eventually look for a bailout — and Shimmy believes that's exactly what happened at the critical late scrum. He also flags the disallowed Arendse try before half-time as a turning-point moment, arguing South Africa's second-half dominance — particularly up front — deserved more reward than it got. His verdict: France won with heart and shouldn't be stripped of credit, but the Boks won't deliver a performance that poor again, and a rematch at Allianz Stadium next weekend (if both sides top their respective tables) would be a very different fixture.