John Plumtree's take is worth noting given his dual vantage point — he's seen both systems up close. His argument: the Springbok prop depth is so strong that a Louw clone would walk into the All Blacks starting XV, which doubles as a pointed observation about where New Zealand is falling short. The piece frames the Rugby's Greatest Rivalry series as instructive for Kiwi teams on how to weaponise the scrum the way South Africa does — suggesting it's not just a personnel gap but a philosophical one.
AnalysisSpringboksSA Rugby Mag
Plumtree: SA's prop depth exposes a New Zealand blind spot
Plumtree argues Springbok prop depth is so pronounced that a Wilco Louw clone would start for the All Blacks — and uses the Rivalry series to highlight what NZ teams need to learn about making the scrum a genuine weapon.
- John Plumtree
- Springboks
- New Zealand
Related stories
Boks remain top but All Blacks close gap to 2.90 points after Nations Championship opener
South Africa stay top of the World Rugby Men's Rankings at 93.94 points but New Zealand have cut the gap to 2.90 after beating France, while Scotland climb to equal their all-time high of fifth following a record 47-38 win over Argentina in Córdoba.
Hansen's Right to Back Himself — But the Boks' Five-Match Streak Tells a Different Story
Jean de Villiers acknowledges Hansen's logic but argues last year's results and performances make it hard to see the All Blacks closing the gap on the Boks — and the panel get genuinely animated over what a 2-2 series tiebreaker would even look like.
Keo & Zels: Stubborn All Blacks policy make Boks smile
The boys love that New Zealand keep picking their second-best, long may it continue.
All Blacks' loosehead crisis hands Springboks a ready-made weapon in Greatest Rivalry Series
Jeff Wilson has publicly identified loosehead prop as the All Blacks' most dangerous weakness ahead of four consecutive Tests against the Springboks — with Williams likely out, Tu'ungafasi's future uncertain, and the remaining options short on caps and experience. Set against the depth Erasmus has built across the prop positions, this piece maps out why scrum time could be where the Greatest Rivalry Series is decided.
Stephen Donald: Robertson copied the Boks — Rennie must go back to All Blacks DNA
Stephen Donald backs Hansen's anti-copycat argument, saying Robertson erred by chasing the Springbok blueprint rather than New Zealand's tempo-based strengths — and expects Rennie to correct that course ahead of a blockbuster four-Test series in South Africa.