Planet Rugby's player ratings from the 21-19 loss to France pin the defeat squarely on two things: Jasper Wiese's red card and the Bomb Squad's failure to convert dominance into a winning margin. Wiese's moment of panic at the breakdown — his second red card in recent memory — is judged the decisive swing in a game decided by margins. The ratings are otherwise surprisingly generous to the starting XV, with Jesse Kriel and Damian de Allende (celebrating his 50th start alongside Kriel) earning 8s for a midfield display that neutralised France in defence and created the Reinach try. Morne van den Berg continues his impressive run with a 7, while Feinberg-Mngomezulu and Willemse share a 4 each for error-strewn nights. The Bomb Squad earned collective praise for dismantling the French scrum — Marx, Nche and Louw all singled out — but the piece argues the finishing punch wasn't there, with Libbok's missed conversion to level the game the symbolic low point. Lood de Jager's yellow card and Kurt-Lee Arendse's controversial penalty call also feature as pivotal officiating moments the piece doesn't let pass without scrutiny.