Gavin Rich argues the Nations Championship has largely justified its existence: when the Boks raced to 31-0 against Italy in Turin, points differential kept neutral viewers engaged right through the final whistle, and it has stacked pressure onto the All Blacks heading into Cardiff. But Rich tempers his endorsement with a structural critique — the competition's integrity is undermined by the fact that not all teams field full-strength sides at the same time. France couldn't go full-strength in New Zealand, and Erasmus deliberately used the Scotland and Wales home games for depth-building experiments rather than margin-chasing, which now skews the differential stakes. Rich's point: the competition rewards teams that prioritised it from the start, which not all coaches could or did. On the laws, Rich sides with Brian Moore that the driving maul has tipped too far — Ewan Ashman's hat-trick being the exhibit — without calling for it to be abolished, just made more defendable. The piece also devotes considerable space to Sandpapergate's revival via Usman Khawaja's book, with Rich firmly on Team Khawaja: Cummins's careful denials don't stack up against the weight of insiders — Warner, Bancroft, Khawaja, Sayyers — who've all pointed the same direction, and Rich uses his own experience ghost-writing Peter de Villiers's memoir to explain why sports autobiographies are rarely motivated by book sales.