Nick Mallett's read on Salmaan Moerat's situation is sobering: withdrawing from the Italy start with back spasms didn't just cost him one cap — it may have cost him his place in the squad entirely. Lood de Jager stepped in and delivered, Etzebeth has since been called up, and with Nortje entrenched as the lineout caller and Mostert holding his own, the lock hierarchy has tightened considerably around Moerat. Mallett draws a direct parallel with Pollard's calf injury in Cape Town — a player primed for a big moment, forced to withdraw, watching the replacement seize the jersey and not letting go. The broader point Mallett makes is structural: in Erasmus's squad, opportunity is rare and unforgiving. When a spot opens and the man who fills it performs, the original incumbent doesn't just slot back in. Both Erasmus and Mallett have gone out of their way to defend Moerat's value — his scrummaging, mauling, and defensive grunt — but the defence of his qualities sits awkwardly alongside the acknowledgement that he may not get back in to demonstrate them.