Ian Cameron's player-by-player breakdown of France's 21-19 win over the Springboks is a study in contrasts. Dupont (9.5/10) earns the standout mark — nominally at flyhalf but effectively playing both nines and tens — while Verhaeghe and Cros are credited as the unsung engine-room contributors who kept France in the game when the wheels threatened to come off. The collective picture is of a French team that dominated for 50 minutes then largely imploded: Grandidier-Nkanang's yellow card, Lucu's missed penalty, and a bench that was comprehensively outmuscled by the Bomb Squad nearly cost them the win they had seemed to bank. Cameron is pointed in his assessment that France won despite their replacement impact rather than because of it, and the ratings reveal a squad with genuine world-class individuals — Dupont, Bielle-Biarrey, Alldritt — but significant depth and discipline questions that will need answering before the World Cup.